Image credits: Tristan deBrauwere and Nate Tangeman.

New, York — The bagel wars have officially come full circle…and this time, the crown is staying in New York. Ess-a-Bagel, the beloved Manhattan institution celebrating 50 years in business, won Best Bagel and Best New York Style at the sold-out 2026 New York BagelFest, presented by King Arthur Baking Company, at Citi Field on Sunday, November 15th.

Its victory over last year’s Best Bagel champion, Dallas-based Starship Bagel, founded by Brooklyn-born Oren Salomon, who took silver in both categories, gave New Yorkers something to schmear about. Yet Starship didn’t leave empty-handed, taking home the gold for Best Sandwich with its Chicago Style Lox Dog. Meanwhile, the winners of the inaugural BagelFest West this past April continued their streaks, with Rise Bagels of Irvine, California making a clean sweep of the People’s Choice in both Los Angeles and New York in 2026, and Seattle’s Hey Bagel rising to the top for Best Sourdough just seven months after claiming Best Bagel.

At New York BagelFest, the Big Apple certainly didn’t have a monopoly on the dough. Rise Bagels of also earned gold awards for Rising Star and Best Beyond the Boroughs, while Bagel Brigade of Hyderabad, India, won Best International. From Queens legends to contenders from across the United States, Canada and Europe, the competition proved the bagel has become a global obsession, even if its heart still beats in New York.

“The 7th New York BagelFest was by far the most competitive yet, with the slimmest margins of victory. Bagel makers from around the world keep pushing the limits of flavor, fermentation, and creativity. But New Yorkers can still say, with confidence, that this is the home of the best bagels for another year. For now,” said BagelFest Founder Sam Silverman.

Twenty-seven bagel exhibitors and 25 additional food and beverage brands came together for the seventh annual celebration, where blind-tasting judges, culinary experts and festivalgoers weighed in across 14 award categories. The sold-out event featured more than 50 booths, live competitions and culinary programming.

For Ess-a-Bagel, the victory was a fitting birthday present. Founded in 1976, the family-run New York staple took top honors in the festival’s blind-tasted Best Bagel competition and the Best New York Style category, edging out a field of acclaimed bakers, including Starship Bagel, the Dallas shop that won the overall title in 2025. “I was shocked. We know we’re a good bagel. We’re 50 years in business, and what an accomplishment in New York City, right?” said Beverly Wilpon, Owner of Ess-a-Bagel. “It’s an invigorating way for us to celebrate.”

For Wilpon, the secret ingredient is continuity. “We think it’s okay that maybe one bagel store just keeps the tradition the same for 50 years, and we’re okay with that. “It’s nice to be part of the community, and it’s nice to be a small business in New York City.” Erica Levy, a third-generation member of the Ess-a-Bagel family, echoed that pride: “There are so many talented bakers here, and to even think we can still compete with these current bakers is just amazing.”

While expert judges crowned a New York veteran, the public handed its top honor to a California upstart. Rise Bagels of Irvine swept People’s Choice, Rising Star and Best Beyond the Boroughs, and also placed second for Best Sandwich with an egg salad creation featuring green onion schmear, chili crisp and a furikake bagel. Rise also received the “Just the fact that we were included in this competition with all the amazing shops from throughout the world, that in itself was already such an honor,” said John Park, Rise Bagels’ chef and owner. “To actually win is just unbelievable.” The team described the logistical hurdles of freezing and shipping bagels and coping with airline disruptions before competing. “I would have been proud regardless of the result. The result is just the icing on the cake.”

India had its own reason to celebrate: Hyderabad’s Bagel Brigade took gold for Best International, ahead of Bodega Bagels of Belfast, Northern Ireland, and SISI Bagels of Madrid, Spain. Montréal’s St-Viateur Bagel earned Best Montreal, underscoring the different regional styles sharing the spotlight.

The day’s award-winning flavor combinations traveled well beyond the traditional everything bagel. Brooklyn’s Bagel Joint won Schmear of the Year for Nước Chấm Cream Cheese, bringing a Vietnamese dipping-sauce inspiration to an Ashkenazi staple, and also won Best Bialy. “We feel really, really proud to represent international food through the lens of Ashkenazi cooking, and could not be prouder of what we put out there,” said Will Sacks, chef and owner of Bagel Joint in Greenpoint, Brooklyn.

Starship Bagel took Best Sandwich for its Chicago Style Lox Dog, a poppy-seed bagel bun topped with rolled Nova lox and Chicago hot-dog fixings, including mustard, relish, pickles and sport pepper. Manhattan’s Bagizza won Most Creative for “Off da 7 Train,” pairing a sesame-perilla bagel with doenjang schmear, house-smoked pastrami and Korean pickle. Sometimes, the wildest ideas are the ones that rise to the top.

Read more about the festival and see the winners here.