The Real Reason Costco Stopped Selling Its All-American Chocolate Cake

January 3, 2022 Mashed

Ah, Costco, the land of low prices, delicious pizza, free samples for days (yes, Costco samples are back!), and the fudgy, chocolatey goodness that is — or was — the All-American Chocolate Cake. For years, this beloved chocolate cake, easily big enough to feed 20 guests or more, was a trusted go-to for birthdays, holiday parties, Mother’s Day celebrations, and more. That is, until the day it unexpectedly disappeared.

Costco Now Has a Mini Version of This Beloved Bakery Item

In 2020, we said goodbye to the All American Chocolate Cake. After some Costco members began to notice that the beloved cake wasn’t being restocked, a Chage.org petition was created to help bring it back. Thus far, more than 7,200 people have signed on in a show of support.